Andrea Gail: Caught in the “Perfect Storm”

On September 20, 1991, the Andrea Gail, a commercial fishing vessel, left Gloucester, Massachusetts, with high hopes for a successful swordfishing trip to the Grand Banks of Newfoundland. However, what was supposed to be a profitable voyage turned into a harrowing tale of survival against nature’s fury. This is the story of the Andrea Gail and the infamous “Perfect Storm” that led to the disappearance of its six-man crew.

The Andrea Gail Sets Sail

Preparation for the Voyage

A scene showing the Andrea Gail from the film The Perfect Storm. Source: Warner Bros. Pictures

The Andrea Gail was no ordinary fishing vessel. It was well-equipped with hundreds of miles of monofilament line, thousands of fishing hooks, and 10,000 pounds of bait. The ship also had seven life preservers, six survival suits, a life raft, and an emergency beacon. Owned by Bob Brown, known as “Suicide Brown” for his risky fishing ventures, the ship was captained by Frank “Billy” Tyne, a seasoned fisherman familiar with the challenges of the Atlantic.

The Crew

The crew of the Andrea Gail included David Sullivan, Alfred Pierre, Bobby Shatford, Dale Murphy, and Michael “Bugsy” Moran. These men were experienced fishermen, ready for the rigors of the trip, and eager to return home with a profitable haul.

Initial Struggles

The crew members of the Andrea Gail. Source: Twitter

The Andrea Gail reached the Grand Banks within a week, but the crew’s luck quickly soured. The fish weren’t biting, and to make matters worse, the ship’s ice machine broke down. Without ice, any fish caught would spoil, so the crew faced a tough decision. Captain Tyne decided to head further east to the Flemish Cap, hoping for a better catch.

The Brewing Storm

Meteorological Chaos

As the Andrea Gail headed east, a series of extreme weather patterns began to converge. Hurricane Grace, a late-season storm, was heading towards the Atlantic coast. At the same time, a massive anticyclone was blocking the Eastern Seaboard. When Grace collided with a low-pressure system from Quebec, it created the conditions for a perfect storm, with massive waves and gale-force winds.

A Glimmer of Hope

Despite the brewing storm, Captain Tyne’s decision to move to the Flemish Cap paid off. The crew finally began to catch swordfish, filling the holds with enough fish to ensure a big paycheck for everyone. By October 27, Tyne decided it was time to head home.

The Perfect Storm Hits

Last Contact

A satellite image capturing the storm. Source: NOAA/ Wikimedia Commons

On October 28, the Andrea Gail made contact with another fishing vessel, the Allison. Tyne reported that they were already experiencing 80-knot winds. His last known communication was with the Hannah Boden, another fishing vessel, where he mentioned the worsening weather and his concerns about the storm.


By October 30, the Andrea Gail was reported missing. The storm, now recognized as the “Perfect Storm,” was causing havoc along the Eastern Seaboard with wind gusts of 70 miles per hour and waves up to 30 feet high. Despite an extensive search by the Coast Guard, there was no sign of the ship or its crew.


On November 5, the ship’s emergency beacon washed ashore on Sable Island, off the coast of Canada. More debris eventually turned up, but the Andrea Gail and its crew were never seen again. The storm caused nearly $500 million in damages and 13 deaths.

The Legacy of the Andrea Gail

Book and Film Adaptation

A Coast Guard cutter navigating through the stormy sea. Source: US Coast Guard

Sebastian Junger’s book, “The Perfect Storm,” published in 1997, detailed the harrowing events and became a bestseller. In 2000, the story was adapted into a film starring George Clooney. While the book was praised for its accuracy, the film was criticized for its dramatized portrayal of events.

Personal Accounts

Linda Greenlaw, captain of the Hannah Boden, disputed the film’s depiction of Captain Tyne and his crew knowingly sailing into a dangerous storm. According to her, the Andrea Gail was already three days into its journey home when the storm hit, and whatever happened to the ship occurred very quickly.

Remembering the Crew

The families and friends of the Andrea Gail’s crew continue to remember their loved ones. Maryanne Shatford, sister of crewman Bob Shatford, appreciated the book’s accuracy but felt the movie focused too much on drama rather than the true story of the crew’s bravery and tragedy.


The story of the Andrea Gail and the “Perfect Storm” serves as a somber reminder of the unpredictability of nature and the bravery of those who venture into the unknown. The six men aboard the Andrea Gail set out for a routine fishing trip and encountered a once-in-a-lifetime storm that sealed their fate. Their story continues to captivate and remind us of the perils faced by those who make their living at sea.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *